labour and greens respond to the community plan
On Tuesday 3 November we held a public meeting at the Friends’ Meeting House. We invited local councillors and MPs. We had previously also sent them a copy of the Brighton Community Plan, and we asked them to come and respond to it in the meeting. Or if they couldn’t attend, to send us a written response.
The Greens sent a councillor to the meeting, who spoke to give support for our plan. The Greens also released a public statement the evening before supporting the plan.
No Labour councillors came to the meeting. We did receive written responses from council leader Bella Sankey, cabinet member for communities Mitchie Alexander, and Hove and Portslade MP Peter Kyle.
The Labour politicians write that they have empathy and concern for our refugee neighbours, and Councillor Mitchie Alexander thanks us for our proposal and commitment. The councillors also state they are “in dialogue” with the Home Office.
But they do not say they support the Community Plan, or that they will join us in working to keep our friends and neighbours in Brighton.
So we need to keep pushing. Brighton & Hove’s council leadership prides itself on being a “City of Sanctuary”. But words are meaningless without action.
Our neighbours are being evicted and “dispersed”. We have come together to stand with them. Hundreds of Brightonians have now donated money, organised fundraisers, offered spare rooms, campaigned and organised in solidarity. Our Council leader has not yet offered any practical support, and has not even come to meet with the residents.
We will continue to call on council leader Bella Sankey to back the campaign.
One simple action you can do: email your local councillor and ask them to urge her to take a stand. You can do this in a minute by clicking on the link here: https://admin.actionnetwork.org/letters/brighton-community-plan
Below are the politicians’ responses in full. Reading the responses from Bella Sankey and Peter Kyle below, it’s not clear they actually read our proposal. Bella Sankey seems to think we are asking to keep the hotel open, rather than find people good, safe housing in our community. And Peter Kyle suggests we talk to Thousand for £1000 – one of the founding groups of our coalition.

Response from council leader Bella Sankey:
Thank you for taking the time to contact me.
We empathise with the points raised about the disruption for anyone moved from asylum accommodation at short notice and the anxiety this causes; we have raised these points directly with the Home Office ourselves.
However it’s important to keep the wider context in mind: substandard hotel accommodation is not a humane response to housing people seeking asylum and so we are supportive of the Government’s efforts to transition away from unsuitable hotel accommodation with limited privacy and no cooking facilities into self-contained accommodation.
We are in continuous dialogue with the Home Office over the remaining residents and we have suggested a community sponsorship model. Currently any decisions lie with Ministers and we are awaiting their response
Response from Peter Kyle MP:
Thank you for your invitation, it’s the kind of invite that makes me very proud of our city and its compassionate and pro-active residents.
I am sorry to say that I won’t be able to make the meeting on Tuesday 3 November as I already have diary appointments in London for that afternoon and evening. However, please be assured that I have listened to the Brighton Says Yes campaign. I am sure you have seen the letter that Brighton & Hove City Council leader Bella Sankey has written to Anna Turley, the Minister for Border Security and Asylum at the Home Office asking for a review of local asylum arrangements. I don’t believe that Bella has received a response yet, I am happy to follow up on this issue if no response is forthcoming.
As you may be aware, the remaining couple of families at the hotel have plans in place that are a result of various council, healthcare and other professional voices liaising with the Home Office. By the time of your meeting, the focus will be on the remaining young women in the hotel.
You may be aware that there are already organisations offering community schemes in the city, such as:
Thousand 4 £1000 Brighton’s community response to enforced homelessness among forced migrants
roomforrefugees.com A national UK network—operating actively in Brighton—that connects volunteer hosts with spare rooms or empty properties to refugees and asylum seekers in need of temporary or medium-term shelter.
If you haven’t already been in touch with them, it may be a useful exercise.
Finally, when I have been in touch with healthcare professionals who work in this area, it has been made very clear to me how vulnerable and often traumatised these lone female asylum seekers are and the need for robust safeguarding systems and oversight. I am sure that you are already bearing this in mind and know that Bella will be meticulous in her planning if the council get the go-ahead for a scheme similar to the Home for Ukraine scheme.
Response from Councillor Mitchie Alexander:
I do fully recognise the concern about the impact on people who have established friendships, support networks and connections in Brighton & Hove, and the anxiety and disruption that can be caused when people are required to move at short notice.
The council shares the ambition of ensuring that people seeking asylum are treated with dignity and are able to live in safe, suitable accommodation with the support they need. We are also supportive of the move away from unsuitable hotel accommodation, which can provide limited privacy and of course no facilities for people to prepare their own food.
It is great that local organisations are thinking constructively about how people might be supported within Brighton & Hove.
Officers are meeting with Home Office regularly to ensure the wellbeing of residents in the hotel. As part of this work we have already raised this kind of model directly with the Home Office and will continue to promote the case for a properly funded scheme that could enable a solution of this kind.
For such an arrangement to be sustainable, however, it would need to be fully funded by the Home Office and based on appropriate and suitable housing, adequate ongoing support and robust safeguarding arrangements for everyone involved. Those elements are essential if any model is to provide people with the security and stability they need.
Decisions about asylum accommodation ultimately rest with the Home Office. We will therefore continue our dialogue with them, including advocating for approaches which enable the council and our local partners to provide effective support to people seeking sanctuary in the city.
Thank you again for putting forward the proposal and for the commitment you and others are showing to people seeking asylum in Brighton & Hove.
Statement from Brighton & Hove Green Party:

Brighton & Hove Greens back the Brighton Says Yes campaign
Brighton & Hove Green Party and our 12 local councillors are proud to put our full support behind the Brighton Says Yes Community Plan.
The aim of the plan is clear: for our community to come together to ensure that all those claiming asylum – especially families, single women and young people – can stay in our city rather than be scattered across the country by the Home Office, away from friends, neighbours, and the city they call home.
As a party committed to fighting for migrant and refugee justice, we take our status as a City of Sanctuary seriously. In June, we were proud to be a part of organising the Carnival Against Fascism that stood firm with our migrant and racialised communities against fascism, racism and state violence. And in July, we brought a motion demanding our City Council ends compliance with cruel Home Office immigration raids. Sadly, Labour wrecked this motion – choosing to pat themselves on the back rather than recognise the continued injustice of hostile Labour immigration policies.
We know that actions speak louder than words. Our City Council should enable our communities to come together and house people seeking asylum with dignity, independence and support.Yet at time of writing, this Labour administration have yet again shown what their solidarity really means – nothing. They must do better.
Together, we must build a city where everyone feels welcome. Greens are united in:
Supporting the Brighton Says Yes campaign and calling on the Council to formally back the plan.
Calling on the government to provide migrants with dignified work, housing and living conditions.
Committing to working with campaigners towards integrating the Community Plan into our Green manifesto for next year’s local elections.
Your Green Councillors will always stand up for our migrant communities.